Quick take
- Test putts and chips first.
- Then check approach shots from 100 yards.
- Check the driver last.
- Pick the ball that scores best, not flies farthest.
Why start at the green?
A typical round has far more shots inside 100 yards than drives. Small differences in how a ball checks or rolls on chips add up fast. Driver differences between similar balls are often just a few yards.
Step 1: Putting
- Hit 10-, 20- and 40-foot putts with each ball.
- Note feel, sound and how consistent your speed is.
- Eliminate any ball that feels wrong to you.
Step 2: Chips and pitches
- Hit 10 chips and 10 pitches (around 20 to 40 yards) with each.
- Watch how far each one releases after landing.
- Pick the one that behaves the way you picture shots.
Step 3: Approach shots
- Hit your favorite scoring club (often a 9-iron or wedge) to a green.
- Check height and how quickly each ball stops.
- Look for consistent carry, not one great shot.
Step 4: Driver
- Hit several drives with your top two balls.
- Compare where they finish, not just the best one.
- Notice which one curves less on your typical miss.
Keep score
Give each ball a simple 1-to-5 score at each step. Weight the short game more.
Narrow the field
Don't test ten balls. Choose two or three that fit your budget and differ in a meaningful way, like one urethane and one ionomer, or one soft and one firmer.
- Two candidates: easiest to compare honestly.
- Three: fine if one is your current ball as a baseline.
- More: differences blur, and you'll remember your best shots, not your average ones.
Read the results
If one ball clearly wins around the green, pick it, even if it's a few yards shorter off the tee. If short-game scores are close, let driver accuracy break the tie. If everything is close, choose the cheaper ball and stick with it for a full season.
Write your scores down right after each step. Memory flatters the ball you already like. A notebook or phone note keeps the test honest.